Buying Guides

Published November 18, 2025

10 min

Best Places to Buy Mattresses: Your Complete Shopping Guide

Helping you navigate brick-and-mortar stores, online retailers, and everything in between.

Nectar Editorial Team

Table of contents

Understanding Your Mattress Shopping OptionsTraditional Mattress Stores: The Hands-On ExperienceOnline Mattress Retailers: Convenience at Your FingertipsDepartment Stores and Warehouse Clubs: The Middle GroundWhat Makes a Great Mattress Store?Smart Shopping Strategies for Any RetailerTrial Periods and Warranties: Your Safety NetCurrent Market Trends and Shopping PatternsRegional Considerations and Local OptionsTiming Your Purchase for Maximum ValueMaking Your Final DecisionSpecial Considerations for Different ShoppersYour Path to Better Sleep Starts Here

Shopping for a new mattress can feel overwhelming. Between the endless options, confusing terminology, and the pressure to make the "right" choice, it's no wonder many people put off such an important purchase. But here's the thing: finding the perfect mattress doesn't have to be complicated. You just need to know where to look – and what to look for.Whether you're searching for a mattress store near you or considering online options, this guide will walk you through everything you need to know about where to buy your next mattress. We'll cover the pros and cons of different retailers, what to expect from each shopping experience, and how to get the best value for your investment.

Understanding Your Mattress Shopping Options

The mattress shopping landscape has changed dramatically over the past decade. While traditional mattress stores still dominate the market, online retailers have carved out a significant space by offering convenience and competitive prices. Understanding the differences between these options will help you choose the best place to buy a mattress for your specific needs.
According to Consumer Reports data, online mattress purchases have actually declined since their 2021 peak, with many shoppers returning to physical stores. This shift highlights an important truth: there's no one-size-fits-all approach to mattress shopping. Your ideal shopping experience depends on your comfort level with online purchases, how much guidance you need, and whether you prefer to test before you buy.

https://media.residenthome.com/contentful/nectar/blog/mattressshopping.webp

Traditional Mattress Stores: The Hands-On Experience

When you search for a mattress store near you, you'll likely find several traditional retailers in your area. These brick-and-mortar locations offer something online shopping can't fully replicate: the ability to test mattresses in person before making a decision.The advantages of shopping at physical mattress stores include:

Immediate tactile feedback on firmness and comfort
Professional guidance from sales associates
Same-day or next-day delivery options
The ability to compare multiple models side by side
Negotiation opportunities on price and extras

However, traditional stores also come with some drawbacks. The shopping experience can feel pressure-filled, with commissioned salespeople eager to close a deal. Prices at physical locations are often higher than online alternatives, though many stores will price match if you find a better deal elsewhere.Consumer Reports members consistently rate their satisfaction highest when they can test a mattress before buying. This hands-on experience proves particularly valuable for couples with different sleep preferences or anyone with specific comfort needs due to back pain or other health concerns.

Online Mattress Retailers: Convenience at Your Fingertips

The rise of bed-in-a-box companies has revolutionized how we shop for mattresses. Online retailers have simplified the buying process, eliminated pushy sales tactics, and often offer better prices than traditional stores. When you're looking for the best place to purchase a mattress without leaving home, online options deliver unmatched convenience.Key benefits of buying mattresses online include:

Shop at your own pace without sales pressure
Compare dozens of options easily
Read thousands of customer reviews
Often lower prices due to reduced overhead
Generous trial periods (typically 90-365 nights)
Free shipping directly to your door

The main challenge with online mattress shopping? You can't test the product before it arrives. That's why reputable online retailers offer extended trial periods. At Nectar, we provide a full 365-night trial — giving you an entire year to ensure your mattress is the right one for your needs. This removes the risk from online shopping, and lets you experience your mattress through different seasons and sleep patterns.

Department Stores and Warehouse Clubs: The Middle Ground

Department stores and warehouse clubs represent a middle ground between specialized mattress retailers and online shopping. These venues often carry a curated selection of popular brands at competitive prices, making them a good place to buy a mattress if you're already a member or regular shopper.Warehouse clubs like Costco and Sam's Club typically offer excellent value, though their selection is limited when compared to dedicated mattress stores. Their shopping experience is more self-service, with minimal sales assistance available. However, generous return policies and member-specific pricing can make them attractive options for budget-conscious shoppers.Department stores provide a different experience altogether. While their mattress departments are usually smaller than specialty stores, they often run significant sales events throughout the year. If you're patient and are able to wait for the right promotion, department stores can offer some of the best deals on quality mattresses.

https://media.residenthome.com/contentful/nectar/blog/mattressshopping-inline2.webp

What Makes a Great Mattress Store?

Whether shopping online or in person, the best mattress stores share several key characteristics that set them apart from the competition. Understanding these factors will help you identify retailers worth your time and money.Essential qualities of top mattress retailers:

Transparent pricing without hidden fees or surprise charges
Knowledgeable staff who educate rather than pressure
Generous trial periods allowing adequate testing time
Clear warranty terms protecting your investment
Flexible return policies if the mattress doesn't work out
Quality brands with proven track records

The best store for your mattress purchase will make you feel informed and empowered throughout your shopping process. They'll answer your questions honestly, explain the differences between models clearly, and respect your budget constraints without pushing unnecessary upgrades.

Smart Shopping Strategies for Any Retailer

Regardless of where you decide to shop, certain strategies will help you find the perfect mattress at the best price. These tips apply whether you're visiting a mattress firm location or browsing online retailers from your couch.Know your sleep position and preferences. Side sleepers typically need softer mattresses that cushion pressure points, while back and stomach sleepers often prefer firmer support. Understanding your needs before shopping helps narrow down options quickly.Research before you visit. Even if you plan to buy in-store, reading online reviews and comparing specifications helps you ask better questions and avoid impulse decisions. Sites like Sleep Foundation and Wirecutter provide unbiased mattress reviews and buying guides worth consulting.Test properly in stores. If you’re shopping in person, spend at least 10-15 minutes on each mattress you're considering. Lie in your typical sleep position and pay attention to pressure points and spinal alignment. Don't feel rushed — this is a significant investment in your health and comfort.Compare total costs, not just sticker prices. Factor in delivery fees, old mattress removal, foundation requirements, and any additional accessories. Online retailers often include these services free, while traditional stores may charge extra.

Trial Periods and Warranties: Your Safety Net

One of the most important factors when choosing where to buy a mattress is the trial period and warranty offered. These policies protect your investment and ensure you're completely satisfied with your purchase.Industry-standard trial periods range from 90 to 365 nights, with most online retailers offering at least 100 nights. This extended testing time matters, since your body often needs time to adjust to a new sleep surface. What feels comfortable for 20 minutes in a store might not work after several weeks of actual use.Warranties protect against manufacturing defects and premature wear. Look for warranties lasting at least 10 years, though some companies offer lifetime coverage. At Nectar, our Forever Warranty demonstrates our confidence in our products' durability and gives you peace of mind for as long as you own your mattress.

Current Market Trends and Shopping Patterns

Understanding current market trends helps you make more informed decisions about when and where to shop. Recent data shows interesting shifts in how consumers approach mattress shopping.While online mattress sales exploded during 2020-2021, there's been a noticeable return to in-store shopping as restrictions have lifted. Many shoppers now use a hybrid approach: researching extensively online before testing out their top choices in stores. This combines the best of both worlds — the wealth of information available online, with the hands-on experience of traditional retail.Price transparency has improved across all channels, with most retailers now clearly displaying prices online. This shift benefits consumers by enabling easier comparison shopping and reducing the effectiveness of high-pressure sales tactics.

Regional Considerations and Local Options

Your location influences your mattress shopping options. Urban areas typically offer more choices, including showrooms for online brands, specialty sleep shops, and multiple traditional retailers. Rural shoppers might have fewer local options but can take advantage of online retailers' free shipping to level the playing field.When searching for the best mattress stores, consider both national chains and local independents. Local stores often provide personalized service and may offer unique brands not found elsewhere. They're also more likely to negotiate on price and throw in extras like free delivery or pillow sets.

Timing Your Purchase for Maximum Value

While you can find good mattress deals year-round, certain times offer better opportunities for savings. Understanding retailer patterns helps you identify the best mattress deals near me and online.Prime times for mattress shopping:

Holiday weekends (Presidents Day, Memorial Day, Labor Day)
End of month when stores need to meet quotas
Model year transitions when retailers clear inventory
Black Friday and Cyber Monday for online deals

However, don't let deal-hunting override your immediate needs. If you're waking up with pain or your mattress is clearly worn out, the cost of waiting for a sale might outweigh the savings. Quality sleep impacts every aspect of your life, making a good mattress one of the best investments you can make.Note: Nectar’s 30 Day Price Guarantee means you don’t have to wait until the actual holiday to shop! You can beat the rush – if our price drops, contact our team and we’ll price match our best price in the last 30 days. Shop Nectar today.

Making Your Final Decision

After researching options and testing possibilities, how do you make the final call on where to purchase a mattress? Focus on value rather than just price. The cheapest option isn't always the best deal if it doesn't meet your comfort needs or wears out quickly.Consider the total package each retailer offers. A slightly higher price might be worth it for superior customer service, better trial terms, or a more comprehensive warranty. Read the fine print on return policies—some retailers charge restocking fees or require you to keep the mattress for a minimum period before returning.Trust your instincts about both the product and the retailer. If something feels off about the shopping experience or the deal seems too good to be true, keep looking. The best place to buy mattresses will make you feel confident and informed about your purchase.

Special Considerations for Different Shoppers

Different life situations call for different shopping approaches. Couples should prioritize retailers offering split firmness options or excellent motion isolation. Those with chronic pain benefit from stores with knowledgeable staff who understand how different constructions affect pressure relief and support.Budget-conscious shoppers should focus on value rather than rock-bottom prices. A quality mattress that lasts 10 years costs less per night than a cheap option that you’ll need to replace after three. Many retailers offer financing options, making higher-quality mattresses accessible through manageable monthly payments.For those relocating soon or living in temporary housing, consider retailers with strong online presence and nationwide coverage. This ensures warranty support and customer service remain accessible regardless of where you move.

Your Path to Better Sleep Starts Here

Finding the best place to buy a mattress depends on your individual needs, preferences, and shopping style. Traditional stores offer immediate gratification and hands-on testing, while online retailers provide convenience, competitive pricing, and generous trial periods. Department stores and warehouse clubs can offer solid value for those willing to work with limited selection.Whatever route you choose, prioritize retailers that put your satisfaction first. Look for transparent pricing, knowledgeable assistance, and policies that protect your investment. Most importantly, choose a retailer that gives you confidence in your purchase through adequate trial periods and comprehensive warranties.At Nectar, we've designed our entire experience around removing the stress from mattress shopping. Our 365-night trial gives you a full year to ensure your mattress is perfect, while our Forever Warranty protects your investment indefinitely. Combined with free shipping and returns, we've eliminated the risk from online mattress shopping while delivering exceptional value and comfort. And with over 6 million happy sleepers, you don’t have to take us at our word.Ready to experience the difference a great mattress makes? Whether you're exploring local mattress stores or considering online options, use this guide to navigate your choices confidently. Your perfect night's sleep is waiting—you just need to know where to find it.